What Is a Care Needs Assessment Under the Care Act 2014?

Updated: Oct 22
A care needs assessment is a structured evaluation of the support a person requires to live safely and maintain an appropriate quality of life. Under the Care Act 2014, local authorities in England must carry out a care needs assessment for any adult who appears to have care and support needs, regardless of their financial situation. This guide explains what the assessment involves, who is entitled to one, what the eligibility test requires, and when an independent assessment provides a more reliable basis for decisions than a local authority assessment.
By Neil Courtney, Senior Independent Social Worker
What is a care needs assessment?
A care needs assessment is a formal process through which a local authority, or an independent social worker, evaluates the day-to-day functioning of an adult and identifies the care and support they need. It looks at what tasks the person struggles with, how those difficulties affect their wellbeing, and what kind of support would address those needs.
The Care Act 2014 introduced a national framework for care needs assessments in England, standardising the eligibility criteria and placing the assessment duty firmly on local authorities. In Wales, the comparable framework is the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014, which sets broadly equivalent requirements.
An independent care needs assessment follows the same framework but is carried out by an independent social worker with no ties to any local authority, NHS body, or care provider. This independence matters in legal, professional, and contested contexts where a local authority's findings may be influenced by funding pressures or resource constraints.
Who is entitled to a care needs assessment?
Under section 9 of the Care Act 2014, a local authority must carry out a care needs assessment for any adult who appears to have care and support needs, or is likely to develop them in the future. The duty is triggered by apparent need, not by a formal application and not by a financial assessment. A person cannot be refused an assessment simply because the local authority thinks they are unlikely to meet the eligibility threshold.
The right to an assessment applies regardless of:
The person's financial situation
Whether they are already receiving care
Whether they have previously been assessed
Whether the local authority expects the person to be self-funding
Carers also have a right to their own assessment under the Care Act 2014. A carer's assessment evaluates the impact of caring responsibilities on the carer's own wellbeing and needs.
The Care Act 2014 eligibility test
After completing a care needs assessment, a local authority must apply the national eligibility criteria to determine whether the person's needs are eligible for local authority support. The eligibility test has three conditions, all of which must be satisfied:
The adult's needs arise from or are related to a physical or mental impairment or illness.
As a result of those needs, the adult is unable to achieve two or more of the specified outcomes.
As a consequence, there is, or is likely to be, a significant impact on the adult's wellbeing.
The ten specified outcomes
The ten specified outcomes are the activities the Act identifies as central to independent living. A person is considered unable to achieve an outcome if they cannot do it safely, without significant pain or distress, in a timely manner, or without assistance. The outcomes are:
Managing and maintaining nutrition
Maintaining personal hygiene
Managing toilet needs
Being appropriately clothed
Being able to make use of the adult's home safely
Maintaining a habitable home environment
Developing and maintaining family or other personal relationships
Accessing and engaging in work, training, education, or volunteering
Making use of necessary facilities and services in the local community, including public transport and recreational facilities
Carrying out any caring responsibilities the adult has for a child
An adult who cannot achieve two or more of these outcomes due to their condition, and who experiences a significant impact on their wellbeing as a result, meets the national eligibility threshold.
What does a care needs assessment involve?
A care needs assessment is a structured conversation and observation carried out in the person's home or care setting. It considers all aspects of the person's daily functioning and how their conditions or disabilities affect their ability to carry out the activities in the eligibility framework.
A thorough assessment involves:
A structured interview with the person, exploring their daily routine, functional difficulties, health conditions, and the tasks they require assistance with
Observation of the person in their home environment
Review of relevant medical records, care plans, and previous assessments where these are made available
Interviews with family members, carers, or support workers where appropriate and with the person's consent
Application of the Care Act 2014 eligible needs framework
A written report setting out findings, the assessed level of need, and recommendations
Neil Courtney, Senior Independent Social Worker, carries out care needs assessments across all 48 counties of England and all 22 counties of Wales. He is registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188).
Local authority assessment or independent assessment?
A local authority care needs assessment is carried out by a local authority social worker or care manager. The assessor works within the local authority's own systems, processes, and resource constraints. While the eligibility criteria are nationally set, the practical application can be affected by local priorities, waiting times, and funding pressures.
An independent care needs assessment is carried out by a qualified social worker who has no employment relationship with the local authority, the NHS, or any care provider. An independent assessor's findings are not shaped by the funding implications of the outcome.
An independent assessment is typically sought in the following circumstances:
A local authority assessment has been refused, delayed, or produced an outcome the family or person disputes
An objective, court-ready expert report is needed for legal or professional proceedings
A solicitor or professional deputy requires an independent evaluation for litigation or deputyship purposes
A family wants a second opinion on whether a care package meets the person's assessed needs
An assessment is needed for a purpose where local authority involvement would create a conflict of interest
What happens after the assessment?
If a local authority assessment concludes that the person's needs are eligible under the Care Act 2014, the authority must prepare a care and support plan setting out how those needs will be met, and allocate a personal budget to fund the provision. Where the person arranges their own care, a direct payment may be made instead.
If the local authority concludes that the person does not meet the eligibility threshold, it must provide written reasons and information about other sources of support. The person has the right to challenge the decision, and an independent assessment that clearly maps their presenting difficulties to the eligible outcomes can be important evidence in a formal challenge or complaint.
For assessments carried out for litigation or Court of Protection purposes, the output is an expert report produced in accordance with the relevant procedural rules, rather than a local authority care and support plan.
When is a private care needs assessment appropriate?
A private care needs assessment, carried out by an independent social worker, is appropriate in a range of circumstances beyond what the local authority process provides:
Personal injury and clinical negligence claims, where the claimant's past and future care needs must be assessed and quantified for a schedule of loss
Court of Protection proceedings, where an objective assessment of care needs is required as evidence
Deputyship matters, where a professional deputy requires an independent review of the care being provided to the person in their care
Care package disputes, where the family or person believes the current provision does not meet assessed needs
Financial vulnerability and safeguarding concerns, where the interaction between care needs and decision-making capacity must be understood
Expert Social Work Assessments provides private care needs assessments for solicitors, professional deputies, care management teams, and families across England and Wales. The care needs assessment and care review service page explains the full range of work available in this cluster. Related guides cover NHS Continuing Healthcare and the Decision Support Tool, how to instruct an independent social worker for a care review.
How to instruct an independent social worker
To instruct Neil or to request a quote, use the referral form on the Contact page. Initial enquiries are also welcome by phone on 0330 043 9054, by mobile or WhatsApp on 07715 638 143, or by email at info@expertswa.co.uk. A free 30-minute telephone or video consultation is available for anyone who wants to discuss their situation before committing to a formal instruction.
Expert Social Work Assessments has no affiliations or ties to any formal care organisation, NHS body, or local authority. Every care needs assessment and report is fully independent, which is why solicitors, professional deputies, care management teams, and families instruct Neil when the findings must stand up to scrutiny.
Frequently asked questions
What is a Care Act assessment?
A Care Act assessment is a care needs assessment carried out under the Care Act 2014. It evaluates whether an adult's needs meet the national eligibility criteria for local authority care and support. The assessment must be offered to any adult who appears to have care and support needs, regardless of their financial situation.
What are eligible needs under the Care Act 2014?
Eligible needs are needs that meet the national threshold: they arise from a physical or mental impairment or illness, they prevent the person from achieving two or more of the ten specified outcomes, and the resulting impact on the person's wellbeing is significant. Local authorities are only required to meet needs that meet this threshold.
Who is entitled to a care needs assessment?
Any adult who appears to have care and support needs, or who is likely to develop them, is entitled to a care needs assessment under section 9 of the Care Act 2014. The entitlement applies regardless of financial means. A local authority cannot refuse to carry out an assessment simply because it expects the person to be self-funding.
Can I get an independent care needs assessment?
Yes. An independent care needs assessment is carried out by a qualified social worker with no ties to any local authority, NHS body, or care provider. It is appropriate where a local authority assessment is disputed, delayed, or has not been offered, and where an objective expert report is required for legal proceedings or Court of Protection matters. Expert Social Work Assessments provides independent care needs assessments across England and Wales.
How long does a care needs assessment take?
The assessment visit itself typically lasts two to four hours. Where medical records and previous assessments are reviewed, additional time is required. A written report follows the visit, and expedited reports are available where court or hearing deadlines require it.
Does a care needs assessment look at my finances?
No. The duty to assess applies regardless of the person's financial situation, and nobody can be refused an assessment because they are expected to self-fund. Any financial assessment happens separately afterwards, when the local authority decides what it may charge toward the cost of the care it provides.




Comments