top of page
You are in Safe Hands

The Golden Rule of Testamentary Mental Capacity

Writer: Neil Courtney
Neil Courtney
Nov 5
3 min read

The golden rule is a recognised best-practice safeguard in will-making. It is associated with Kenward v Adams (1975) and is designed to protect a person's wishes when their testamentary capacity may later be questioned.


It is particularly relevant where a testator (the person who's will it is) is elderly, seriously ill, living with dementia or another cognitive impairment, or making a will in circumstances that could lead to concern or dispute.


What does the golden rule require?

Where there is a reasonable concern about capacity, the golden rule advises that the will should be approved by a medical or social care practitioner who is satisfied (from carrying out a robust mental capacity assessment) that the testator has testamentary capacity.


The golden rule is not a legal rule that automatically determines whether a will is valid. It is a professional and evidential safeguard that can provide valuable contemporaneous evidence of the testator's capacity.


Why does the rule matter?

A will may be challenged many years after it was signed, when memories have faded and the testator can no longer explain their decisions. A contemporaneous mental capacity assessment and comprehensive report can help record the testator's condition and understanding at the time the will was made.


This can protect the testator's wishes and help reduce the risk of costly disputes. It can also help solicitors demonstrate that appropriate care was taken when preparing the will.


How does it relate to testamentary capacity?

The legal test for testamentary capacity comes from Banks v Goodfellow (1870). In broad terms, a testator should be able to:

  • understand that they are making a will and understand its effect

  • understand the general nature and extent of their property

  • understand and appreciate the claims of people who might reasonably expect to benefit

  • make decisions without a mental disorder or delusion that affects the dispositions in the will


A robust mental capacity assessment can help address these issues, although the legal question of capacity remains for the court if the will is later challenged. Our court compliant mental-capacity-assessmentmental capacity assessments can provide evidence and assist the court in determining capacity.


When should the golden rule be considered?

The safeguard should be considered whenever testamentary capacity could reasonably be questioned, including where the testator is:

  • elderly or physically frail

  • diagnosed with dementia, Alzheimer's disease or another cognitive impairment

  • seriously ill or receiving end-of-life care

  • making unusual or controversial changes, such as excluding close family members

  • appearing vulnerable to pressure or undue influence


What are the limits of the golden rule?

Following the golden rule does not guarantee that a will cannot be challenged, and failing to follow it does not automatically make a will invalid.


The appropriate steps depend on the individual circumstances. A capacity assessment should be carried out by a suitably qualified professional like an independent social worker and should be approached with care, respect and sensitivity.


Practical takeaway

The golden rule is best understood as a precautionary evidential safeguard. Where capacity may reasonably be questioned, obtaining and preserving a contemporaneous medical assessment can help protect the testator's wishes and reduce the risk of future disputes.


If you or a loved one, or a client are preparing or updating a will and there is a belief that testamentary capacity may be questioned later, we can conduct a professional mental capacity assessment that will be appropriate to your circumstances.


We can complete a robust mental capacity assessment to test whether the individual has the requisite capacity to create a new will, change or even revoke an existing will. Contact us here for further details and a quote.


This article is for general information only and is not legal or medical advice. Each situation should be assessed on its own facts.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Court Compliant COP3 Assessments

Navigating the complexities of mental capacity assessments can feel overwhelming. The jargon, the language of the legislative framework and the processes can all seem alien to the lay person. Sp let m

 
 
How EHCP Social Worker Services Support Families

Navigating the world of Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) can feel overwhelming. Families often face complex decisions about their child’s needs and the support available. This is where expert

 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page