Gifting Mental Capacity Assessments

Re Beaney (Deceased) [1978] 1 WLR 770
The test for capacity to make a gift follows the same test as testamentary capacity, using the Banks v Goodfellow (1870) principles. The degree of understanding needed to make a valid lifetime gift depends on the size and nature of the gift.
Gifting Mental Capacity Assessment
Rules for gifting property to family members
01
Willing transfer
The transfer should be done willingly by the donor.
04
Registered ownership
The owner's name must be listed in the Land Registry's proprietorship register.
02
Sound mind
The donor should be of sound mind.
05
Relinquishing all rights
The grantor must give up all rights to the property and change the title into the grantee's name.
03
No outstanding debts
There should be no outstanding debts against the property.
06
Willing acceptance
The grantee must accept the gift willingly and take physical possession of the home.
Nature and Effect of the Transaction

The test for capacity to make a gift follows the same test as that of testamentary capacity that uses Banks v Goodfellow from 1870 principles. In the assessment, the assessor must be satisfied that the person making the gift understands:
Nature of the Transaction
- That it is a gift NOT a loan or any other form of advancement.
- Enquire whether they expect to receive anything back in return.
- When they intend for the gift to take effect.
- The fact that they will not be able to request for the gift back if it was made outright.
- If there was any underlying purpose for the gift.
The Effect of the Gift
-
The effect the gift will have on their own standard of living, now and in the future.
-
All the circumstances, including their ages, lifestyle, income etc.
-
The effect it will have on the recipient.
The Extent of the Property
-
The property they intend to dispose of belongs to them and they have the right to give it as a gift.
-
The extent or possible value of the gift.
-
The effect it will have on their property and wealth.
The Claim to which the giver ought to give effect
-
The people who make the gift must be able to comprehend and appreciate the claim of the potential beneficiaries under their will intestacy:
-
The effect the gift will have could have on other beneficiaries.
-
Why the recipient is more deserving of the will than the other.
-
Whether they think they will have to compensate others by making a new will.
LEGAL AUTHORITIES
Relevant Case Law
[1978] 1 WLR 770 · [1978] 2 ALL ER 595
Re Beaney (Deceased)
Established important principles regarding the mental capacity required to make a lifetime gift. The degree of understanding needed to make a valid lifetime gift depends on the size and nature of the gift.
- Relative Capacity: The greater the value or significance of the gift, the higher the level of understanding needed.
- Understanding the Gift: The donor must understand the fact that they are making a gift, the nature of the gift, and the consequences of making that gift. This is about the ability to understand, rather than actual understanding.
- Undue Influence: A gift can be invalidated if it was made under coercion or undue pressure.
If the subject matter and value of the gift is trivial in relation to the donor's other assets, a low degree of understanding is sufficient. However, if the effect of the gift is to dispose of the donor’s only asset of value and so pre-empt the devolution of their estate under their will or on their intestacy, the donor must have the same degree of understanding as they would need for making a will. The donor has to understand the claims of all potential donees and the extent of the property to be disposed of.
[2014] EWHC 3926 (CH)
Kicks v Leigh
As in the case of wills, there has been uncertainty about whether the common law test has been superseded by the MCA 2005 test for lifetime gifts. The High Court reviewed the conflicting case law and concluded that the common law test is the correct test. As with the test for capacity to make a will, an appellate court might reach a different conclusion in due course.
[2023] EWHC 1145 (CH)
Baker, Spiers v Hewston
The judge referred to the Kicks case, and said that the MCA 2005 and the common law approach could be ‘synthesised’ as they are analytically consistent so as to avoid inconsistent application of them.

Beneficiary Rights
The people who make the gift must be able to comprehend and appreciate the claim of the potential beneficiaries under their will or intestacy, including the effect the gift could have on other beneficiaries, why the recipient is more deserving than the others, and whether they think they will have to compensate others by making a new will.
The common law test is set out in Re Beaney [1978] 2 All ER 595, which says that the degree of understanding needed to make a valid lifetime gift depends on the size and nature of the gift. If the subject matter and value of the gift is trivial in relation to the donor's other assets, a low degree of understanding is sufficient. However, if the effect of the gift is to dispose of the donor’s only asset of value and so pre-empt the devolution of their estate under their will or on their intestacy, the donor must have the same degree of understanding as they would need for making a will.
The donor has to understand the claims of all potential donees and the extent of the property to be disposed of.
Contact us Today to Start Your Assessment
Planning a gift of property to a family member? A professional capacity assessment, grounded in Re Beaney and Banks v Goodfellow principles, helps ensure the gift stands up to scrutiny.

