Section 21a DoLS Challenges

Expert Independent Social Work assessments and robust expert evidence in the Court of Protection
Role of an Independent Social Worker in S.21A Proceedings

As Independent Social Workers we are usually instructed by Local Authorities and / or Solicitors from either side due to our neutrality and specialist expertise. The cases are usually complex and require a high degree of analytical skills to provide clarity to the case. We assist the Court in determining the facts and then ultimately what is in P's Best Interests.
The following are areas we can assist the Court:
1. Independent Capacity Assessment
-
We can be instructed to conduct an assessment to determine whether P has capacity to make decisions about residence, care, and safety.
-
We will also provide a clear, evidence‑based professional opinion on the presence of fluctuating capacity.
-
We will assist the Court to determine whether the DoLS Authorisation meets the statutory qualifying requirements.
2. Best‑Interests Analysis
-
We can be instructed to provide a professional evaluation as to whether the current placement is the least restrictive option.
-
We can be instructed to consider alternative placements, including less restrictive community options, or even increased support if required.
-
We can provide a conclusion with a balanced view when the parties cannot reach agreement about what is in P’s best interests.

3. Assessment of Wishes, Feelings, and Objections
-
We will visit P and gain their wishes and feelings.
-
We will analyse any expressed or behavioural objections, while analysing the frequency, intensity, consistency, emotional state, and attempt to identify triggers.
-
We adhere to case law (RD & Ors (2016)), which guides us on how objections should be considered.
4. Review of Care Plans and Risk Management
-
We will analyse and provide a professional opinion on whether the current care arrangements are appropriate, proportionate and safe.
-
We will review and potentially identify any unmet needs, any overly restrictive care practices or revisions.
5. Expert Evidence for the Court
-
We will carry out the instructed assessments, provide a robust comprehensive report and attend hearings to give oral evidence.
-
We will be able to provide an independent, impartial perspective when neither side can reach agreement.
-
Ultimately, we will assist the Court with our expert analysis of P's often complex situation which can be exacerbated when multiple agencies are involved.

Expert Evidence for S.21a COP Proceedings
Instructing an ISW provides the Court with the necessary independence and professional oversight to determine residence and care outcomes.

