PROFESSIONAL CONSULTANCY
Trustee Mental Capacity Assessments
A trustee’s mental capacity is assessed under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, focusing on whether they can understand, retain, use/weigh and communicate decisions required by the specific trust.
A Trustee has core legal duties when managing a Trust. In England and Wales the legislative framework that governs the duties of the Trustee is the Trustee Act 2000 and also the Trust's deed. The main dutues are:
-
To act in the best interests of beneficiaries in every decision and act.
-
To adherence to the terms of the trust as per the trust deed or will.
-
To exercise reasonable care and skill, with higher standards for professional trustees.
-
To responsibly manage, maintain and protect the assets of the which could include property and / or investments.
-
To avoid acting in a way that is a conflict of interest and to never personally profit from the role unless this is permitted.
-
To keep accurate records and accounts of all trust related income, capital, and decisions.
-
To act without opposition and with the agreement of co‑trustees unless the trust says otherwise.
-
To be prudent when investing, taking professional advice while ensuring suitability.
Trustees may also need to handle the financial aspects of creating tax returns, maintainn communication with beneficiaires and liasing with the appropriate professionals.
The Role of a Trustee

Legal Framework
Presumption of Capacity
Every adult trustee is assumed to have capacity unless it is established, on the balance of probabilities, that they lack it.
The Diagnostic Test
Is there an impairment of, or disturbance in the functioning of, the mind or brain, whether temporary or permanent?
The Functional Test
Can the trustee understand, retain and weigh the relevant information, and communicate a decision by any means?
Causative Nexus
Any inability to make the decision must be caused by the identified impairment, not by other factors such as unwise choices.
Decision-Specific Assessment
Capacity is assessed for the specific trustee decision at the time it needs to be made, reflecting its complexity and consequences.
Practicable Support
A trustee is not treated as lacking capacity until all practicable steps to help them make the decision have been taken without success.
The Assessment Process
A clear, structured pathway from first contact to a robust, comprehensive written report.

01
Referral & Scoping
Trustees, solicitors or family members make an initial referral. We discuss the specific decisions in question, review relevant background information and agree the scope, timescales and format of the assessment.

02
The Assessment Meeting
We meet the individual in a setting where they feel comfortable. Using a person-centred approach in line with the Mental Capacity Act 2005, we explore their understanding of the relevant decisions and the information needed to make them.

03
Report Delivery
You receive a clear, evidence-based written report setting out our findings and reasoning on capacity for each decision, ready to support trustees and legal advisers in acting with confidence.

