
Retrospective Mental Capacity Assessments
Retrospective Mental Capacity Assessments are Expert evaluation of past decisions for legal disputes, including but not limited to Testamentary, Litigation, LPA, Deputyship, Property & Affairs and Care.
The Evidence Framework for Retrospective Mental Capacity Assessments

Determining whether a person had capacity at a specific point in the past requires a careful reconstruction of their decision-making ability. Each assessment applies the statutory test to the evidence available for the relevant time and decision.
- Medical history – GP and hospital records, diagnoses, medication and cognitive test results.
- Contemporaneous notes – care plans, social care records and professional notes made at the time.
- Witness testimony – statements from family, carers and professionals who observed the person.
- Documents of the decision – wills, deeds, correspondence and solicitor attendance notes.
CRITERIA & EVIDENCE
WHEN IT IS NEEDED
Situations that call for a retrospective assessment
When a past decision is questioned, an independent review of the person's capacity at that time can provide clarity for families, solicitors and the courts. This can be after the individual has gone on to lose capacity to make that decision or even if they have passed away.
⚖
Contested Wills
Evaluating whether testamentary capacity was present when a will or codicil was made or changed.
⌂
Property Transfers
Reviewing capacity at the time a home or land was sold, gifted or transferred to another party.
£
Financial Gifts
Assessing whether significant gifts, loans or past financial decisions were made with capacity.
✎
LPA Disputes
Determining whether a Lasting Power of Attorney was validly made when its creation is challenged.
⌂
Property Transfers
Reviewing capacity at the time a home or land was sold, gifted or transferred to another party.
Healthcare Decisions
Reviewing capacity at the time a major Healthcare decision was made, i.e., moving into a care home.
⌂
Litigation
Reviewing capacity for a specific time period for conducting proceedings / litigation.
Our Assessment Process
A structured, transparent process for producing a robust, evidence based retrospective report, with timelines agreed at the outset.
Phase 01: Referral
We discuss the instruction, the decision in question and the relevant date. The scope, fee and expected timeline are confirmed in writing before work begins.
Phase 02: Record Review
Medical, care and social records are carefully examined, alongside witness accounts where available, to build an evidence-based picture of the person's functioning at the relevant time.
Phase 03: Expert Report
A clear, reasoned report is prepared against the relevant legislative framework (i.e., theMental Capacity Act framework), setting out findings and an opinion on capacity, delivered within the agreed timeframe.

