How to Instruct an Independent Social Worker for a Care Review

Updated: Oct 22
A care package that no longer fits the person it was set up for is common, and it can be hard to evidence. An independent care review gives you a professional view of whether the current care meets the person's needs, in a form that a solicitor, a deputy, a local authority or a family can act on. This guide explains who instructs a care review, what to send, what happens at the visit, what the report covers and how to instruct.
By Neil Courtney, Senior Independent Social Worker. Registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188).
What is an independent care review?
An independent care review is a robust review of an existing care provision. That can be care at home, residential care, nursing care or supported living. It uses the Care Act 2014 framework to decide whether the current care meets the person's needs, and it makes recommendations for any changes. In Wales the equivalent framework is the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014.
A care review is different from a care needs assessment. An assessment establishes what care a person needs. A review tests whether the care already in place meets those needs. For the wider picture, read What Is a Care Review and When Should You Request One? or see our page on independent care needs assessments and care reviews.
Who instructs a care review?
Solicitors, in personal injury, clinical negligence and Court of Protection matters where the adequacy of current care is in issue
Professional deputies, who need an objective view of the care arrangements for the person they act for
Care management teams, where a complex or disputed care package needs an independent opinion
Families and self-funders, who can instruct directly without a solicitor or a local authority
Solicitors instructing for Court of Protection work may also find our solicitor's guide to instructing an independent social worker for Court of Protection useful.
When is a care review worth instructing?
The person has left hospital and their care needs have changed
Their condition has deteriorated and the current package no longer seems enough
The family has concerns that a care package arranged by a local authority is not meeting their needs
The person is moving from one care setting to another
A safeguarding incident or a concern about the adequacy of care has been raised
A solicitor needs independent evidence of whether current care arrangements are reasonable
What to include in your instruction
A clear instruction saves time and makes the report more useful. Where you can, provide:
The name and address of the person, and the setting where the review will take place
A description of the current care: the type of care, who provides it and how much is in place
A summary of the concerns, including what has changed and any incidents or observations
Existing care plans, assessments and reviews
Relevant medical records or summaries, where they are available and can properly be shared
The purpose of the report, such as litigation, Court of Protection, a deputy's welfare review or a private review
The specific questions you want answered, and any deadlines or hearing dates
If some documents are not available at the start, the review can still go ahead on the basis of the visit. Further documents can be reviewed and reflected in the report afterwards.
What happens at the visit
Neil Courtney carries out the visit in person, where the person lives or receives care. It typically takes between two and four hours, depending on the person's needs and the complexity of the case. The approach is person-centred and unrushed. The visit usually involves:
A conversation with the person about how their care is working and what has changed
Observation of the person in their care environment
A review of the care plan and care records available on site
Conversations with carers, family members or support workers where appropriate and with the person's consent
An assessment of whether the care in place matches the person's needs
Familiar faces are welcome to be present if the person consents. Communication preferences are captured in the referral form so the visit suits the person.
What the report covers
The person's background, living circumstances and care history
Their current functioning across the relevant areas of daily life
The care package in place and how it is delivered
An analysis of the match between needs and provision, including any gaps or shortfalls
Professional conclusions on whether the current care meets the person's needs
Recommendations for any changes to the care package
Where the report is for litigation, it is prepared as expert evidence in line with CPR Part 35. Where it is for Court of Protection proceedings, it is prepared to the standard those proceedings require.
How the report is used
As evidence in Court of Protection proceedings about whether current care arrangements are in the person's best interests
To support a request for a review of a local authority care and support plan, or a complaint about it
As expert evidence in personal injury and clinical negligence claims
By a professional deputy reviewing the care of the person they act for
By a family who want independent confirmation of whether a relative's care is adequate
As supporting evidence where a safeguarding concern has been raised
Fees and timescales
Quotes are bespoke. They are issued after we receive a completed referral and information-gathering form, and there is no fixed price list. A postcode is needed so that travel can be accounted for accurately. Timescales are confirmed when you instruct, and expedited reports are available where court or hearing deadlines require it.
Independent, across England and Wales
Expert Social Work Assessments has no affiliations or ties to any formal care organisation, NHS body or local authority, and does not recommend any particular care agency. Neil carries out in-person care reviews across all 48 counties of England and all 22 counties of Wales.
Frequently asked questions
How do I instruct an independent social worker for a care review?
Contact Expert Social Work Assessments by phone, email or through the contact page. Give a short description of the person's situation, the current care arrangements, the concerns behind the instruction and any deadlines. A bespoke quote is issued once a completed referral and information-gathering form is received, and the visit is then arranged. A free 30-minute consultation is available first if you want to talk it through.
What should a letter of instruction for a care review include?
Identify the person to be assessed and where they live. Describe the current care arrangements, set out the concerns, state the purpose of the report (for example litigation, Court of Protection or a welfare review) and list the specific questions you want answered. Add any deadlines and attach existing care plans, assessments and relevant medical summaries.
Can a family member instruct a care review?
Yes. A family member or self-funder can instruct a care review directly, without a solicitor or a local authority. The process and the standard of the report are the same. If legal proceedings follow, tell us at the outset so the report can be prepared to the standard those proceedings need.
Can an independent care review be used to challenge a local authority care package?
A report that finds the current care does not meet the person's needs gives you professional evidence to support a request for a review of the care and support plan, a complaint to the local authority or a referral to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. It does not bind the local authority, and the right route depends on the facts of the case.
Can a care review be carried out in a care home?
Yes. A care review covers care at home, residential care, nursing care and supported living. The visit takes place where the person lives and receives their care.
How long does an independent care review take?
The visit typically takes between two and four hours, depending on the person's needs and the complexity of the case. The written report follows the visit, and the timescale is confirmed when you instruct. Expedited reports are available where court or hearing deadlines require it.
How to instruct a care review
To instruct Neil Courtney or to request a quote, use the referral form on the contact page or get in touch directly. A free 30-minute telephone or video consultation is available before you commit to a formal instruction.
Phone: 0330 043 9054
Mobile and WhatsApp: 07715 638 143
Email: info@expertswa.co.uk




Comments