top of page
You are in Safe Hands

What Is a Care Review and When Should You Request One?

Writer: Neil Courtney
Neil Courtney
Sep 28
6 min read

A care review is a reassessment of whether an existing care package continues to meet a person's needs. Care needs are not static — they change with illness, injury, hospitalisation, deterioration, or simply the passage of time. A care package that was appropriate twelve months ago may now be insufficient, excessive, or no longer the right type of support. This article explains what a care review involves, when it is appropriate to request one, and how an independent social worker can carry out a review that is free from the resource pressures that can affect local authority practice.

What is a care review?

A care review is a structured reassessment of a person's existing care arrangements. It considers whether their current needs are being met by the support in place, whether their needs have changed since the original assessment or the last review, and whether any adjustments to the care package are warranted.

Under the Care Act 2014, local authorities in England have a duty to review a care and support plan at least every twelve months, and at any other time if the person, their carer, or any person involved in their care requests a review. In practice, local authority reviews can be delayed or superficial — and a formal request does not always produce a timely or thorough outcome.

An independent care review, carried out by an independent social worker, applies the same framework but without the funding pressures or institutional constraints that can shape local authority decisions. Independent reviews are appropriate when the family or person disputes the adequacy of the current package, when legal or court proceedings require an objective assessment, or when a professional deputy needs a reliable picture of whether the current care arrangements remain appropriate.

When should a care review be requested?

A care review is appropriate in any of the following situations:

  • A person has been discharged from hospital and their care needs have changed as a result

  • A person's underlying condition has deteriorated and the existing care package no longer meets their needs

  • A person has improved and the current package may be more than is now required

  • A family has concerns that the care being provided does not address the person's actual needs

  • A professional deputy needs to review whether the care arranged under the deputyship remains appropriate

  • There has been a safeguarding incident or a concern raised about the quality or adequacy of care

  • A person is moving from one care setting to another — from hospital to a care home, from residential care to supported living, or from one property to another

  • A care package was arranged privately and has never been reviewed against an objective framework

  • A solicitor requires an independent assessment for litigation, personal injury, or Court of Protection proceedings

The Care Act 2014 confirms that any person receiving a care and support plan is entitled to request a review at any time. A local authority cannot refuse to review a plan simply because the last review was recent, or because it considers the package adequate.

What does a care review involve?

A care review is conducted in the person's home or care setting. It typically involves:

  • A structured conversation with the person about how their current care arrangements are working, what is and is not being met, and how their needs have changed

  • Observation of the person in their care environment

  • A review of the existing care plan, the current care package, and any documentation describing recent changes to the person's condition

  • Consultation with carers, family members, or support workers where appropriate and with consent

  • Consideration of whether the current provision meets the person's assessed needs and any unmet needs

  • A written report setting out findings, recommendations, and — where relevant — a proposed revised care plan

Neil Courtney, Senior Independent Social Worker, carries out independent care reviews across all 48 counties of England and all 22 counties of Wales. He is registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188).

What is the difference between a care needs assessment and a care review?

A care needs assessment establishes what level and type of care a person requires. It is carried out when care needs are being assessed for the first time, when a local authority assessment is disputed, or when a formal expert assessment is required for legal proceedings.

A care review assesses whether an existing care package continues to meet those needs. It presupposes that a previous assessment has taken place and that care is already being provided or has been arranged. Where a person's situation has changed substantially, a care review may effectively become a reassessment — establishing needs afresh in light of the changed circumstances.

In practice, the distinction matters less than the question being answered. Whether the brief is to assess needs from scratch or to evaluate whether existing provision meets them, both require the same professional rigour and the same written output suitable for use in legal, court, or professional proceedings.

How does an independent care review support legal and professional proceedings?

An independent care review provides an objective, evidence-based account of whether a person's current care is meeting their needs. In legal and professional contexts, this is often more valuable than a local authority review, which may be influenced by funding considerations or may have been produced by the same service responsible for commissioning the care being reviewed.

Independent care reviews are used in the following professional contexts:

  • Court of Protection proceedings, where a professional deputy or the court requires an assessment of whether current care arrangements are in the person's best interests

  • Personal injury and clinical negligence litigation, where the claimant's care arrangements must be assessed as part of a schedule of loss

  • Deputyship welfare reports, where the deputy needs to demonstrate that the care being provided under the deputyship is appropriate

  • Local authority challenge proceedings, where a family or advocate is disputing the adequacy of the publicly funded care package

  • Safeguarding investigations, where an independent view of the care arrangements is required as part of the investigation

What is the difference between a local authority care review and an independent care review?

A local authority care review is carried out by a social worker or care manager employed by the local authority. The reviewer works within the local authority's own systems and resource constraints. Reviews are often conducted remotely or by telephone, rather than in person, and the conclusions may reflect the local authority's available provision rather than the person's actual needs.

An independent care review is carried out in person, in the care environment, by a qualified social worker with no institutional connections to the local authority, the NHS, or any care provider. The findings are driven by the person's actual needs and the adequacy of the current provision — not by what is locally available or affordable.

For any matter where the care review's conclusions may be scrutinised in legal or professional proceedings, an independent review carried out by a suitably qualified practitioner will carry considerably more weight than a local authority review.

Frequently asked questions

What is a care review?

A care review is a reassessment of whether an existing care package continues to meet a person's needs. It is required at least annually under the Care Act 2014, and can be requested at any time. A review considers whether the person's needs have changed since the last assessment, whether the current provision matches those needs, and what changes — if any — are required.

When should a care package be reviewed?

A care package should be reviewed when there has been a material change in the person's circumstances or condition — following a hospitalisation, a significant deterioration, a move to a new care setting, or a safeguarding concern. It should also be reviewed when the family or person believes the current provision is not meeting needs, regardless of when the last review took place. The Care Act 2014 entitles any person receiving care to request a review at any time.

How do I request a care review?

To request a local authority care review, write to the person's allocated social worker or care manager and state clearly that you are requesting a formal review of the care and support plan under section 27 of the Care Act 2014. Keep a copy of the request. If you need an independent review — for legal proceedings, a disputed local authority package, or a deputyship matter — contact Expert Social Work Assessments directly.

Can a professional deputy request a care review?

Yes. A professional deputy appointed by the Court of Protection has a responsibility to keep the welfare of the person in their care under review. This includes reviewing whether the current care arrangements are appropriate, whether they represent good value, and whether they continue to meet the person's assessed needs. An independent social worker can carry out a welfare review on behalf of a professional deputy.

How long does a care review take?

The review visit typically takes two to four hours. A written report follows. Timescales depend on the urgency of the instruction and are agreed at the point of instruction. Expedited reports are available for court or hearing deadlines.

Request an independent care review

To instruct Neil Courtney for an independent care review, contact Expert Social Work Assessments. A free 30-minute consultation is available to discuss your situation before committing to a formal instruction.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Court Compliant COP3 Assessments

Navigating the complexities of mental capacity assessments can feel overwhelming. The jargon, the language of the legislative framework and the processes can all seem alien to the lay person. Sp let m

 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page