When Can a GP No Longer Complete a COP3 Assessment?

In October 2023, NHS England removed the contractual obligation for GPs to complete COP3 Part B assessments. This change — set out in the NHS England Primary Medical Services and List Management Directions 2023 — means that many GPs are now declining to carry out this work, leaving solicitors, professional deputies, and families searching for alternatives. This article explains what happened, what it means in practice, and why an independent social worker is now the primary route for most Court of Protection assessments in England and Wales.
What Is the COP3 Form and Why Does It Matter?
The COP3 is the official capacity assessment form required for every deputyship application in the Court of Protection. Part A is completed by the applicant or their solicitor. Part B must be completed by a registered healthcare professional with the skills and knowledge to assess mental capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
Without a valid COP3, a deputyship application cannot proceed. Courts require a clear, structured assessment confirming whether the individual lacks capacity to make the specific decisions covered by the deputyship — and why.
For a full explanation of the form itself, see: What Is the COP3 Form and Who Can Complete It?
What Changed in October 2023?
Prior to the NHS England Primary Medical Services and List Management Directions 2023, completing COP3 assessments sat within the broad scope of a GP's NHS contractual duties. Many GPs completed them as a matter of course — sometimes as an enhanced service, sometimes simply as part of general patient care.
The 2023 Directions removed this obligation. GPs are no longer required to undertake mental capacity assessments for Court of Protection purposes as part of their NHS contract. This is not a blanket ban — a GP can still choose to complete a COP3 if they are satisfied they have the relevant skills — but they are under no obligation to do so, and many practices have now adopted a formal policy of declining these requests.
Why Did This Change Happen?
Several factors drove the change:
Growing clinical complexity: COP3 assessments require a structured understanding of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 framework, the two-stage test, and the specific decision in question. This goes beyond what a standard GP consultation is designed to cover.
Time pressures: a proper COP3 assessment cannot be completed in a standard 10-minute appointment. Many GPs reported being asked to complete the form based on a brief review of medical records rather than a thorough assessment.
Medico-legal exposure: as Court of Protection work has increased, GPs have become increasingly cautious about the professional risk attached to capacity assessments they feel unequipped to carry out.
NHS resource constraints: with GP practices under sustained demand pressure, extended assessment work for third parties sits outside the core clinical mission.
The result is a significant practical gap that falls disproportionately on solicitors and professional deputies who are trying to move deputyship applications forward.
Who Can Complete COP3 Part B Now?
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 does not restrict who can assess capacity. The key requirement is that the assessor has the skills and competence to carry out the assessment properly, and the knowledge to apply the two-stage test correctly. COP3 Part B can be completed by any registered practitioner who meets these criteria.
In practice, the professionals now completing the majority of COP3 assessments include:
Independent social workers — registered with Social Work England (SWE) or Social Care Wales, with specialist expertise in mental capacity and Court of Protection work
Consultant psychiatrists — appropriate where there is a significant psychiatric diagnosis alongside capacity concerns
Neuropsychologists — for cases involving acquired brain injury, dementia, or neurological conditions
Occupational therapists — in cases where the capacity question relates primarily to functional capacity
Clinical psychologists — where cognitive assessment is central to the capacity determination
For most deputyship applications — where the individual has dementia, a learning disability, a stroke, or another condition affecting decision-making — an independent social worker is now the most accessible and cost-effective route. They are trained specifically in mental capacity law and the Court of Protection rules, and their assessments are accepted by the courts as a matter of course.
Why an Independent Social Worker Is Often the Right Choice
A specialist independent social worker brings a combination of skills that is well-matched to the COP3 assessment. Unlike a medical practitioner whose primary focus is diagnosis, a social worker is trained to assess the functional impact of a condition on a person's ability to make specific decisions — which is precisely what the Mental Capacity Act two-stage test requires.
The assessment considers:
Whether the person has an impairment of, or disturbance in the functioning of, the mind or brain (Stage 1 of the two-stage test)
Whether that impairment means the person is unable to understand, retain, use, or weigh information, or communicate a decision (Stage 2)
The specific decision or decisions covered by the deputyship application
Whether the lack of capacity is time-specific or likely to be permanent
The person's previously expressed wishes and values, as required by the Act
Neil Courtney is registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188). He is fully independent — no affiliations to any formal care organisation — and covers all 48 counties of England and all 22 counties of Wales for in-person assessments, with overseas work supported by video link.
For a full overview of what a mental capacity assessment involves, visit the mental capacity assessment hub page.
What If My GP Has Already Refused?
If your patient's or client's GP has declined to complete COP3 Part B — either citing the 2023 Directions or a practice policy — this is now a common situation and the resolution is straightforward: instruct an independent practitioner directly.
You do not need the GP's involvement, their agreement, or their referral. The Court of Protection requires a COP3 completed by a suitably qualified professional. It does not require that professional to be a GP, and there is no requirement for the assessor to have prior knowledge of the person.
In many cases, a fresh assessment by an independent social worker who has no pre-existing clinical relationship with the individual is actually preferable from a Court of Protection perspective, because it removes any appearance of a prior relationship influencing the outcome.
Practical Guidance for Solicitors and Professional Deputies
If you are managing a deputyship application and need COP3 Part B completed:
Do not delay the application waiting for a GP to agree. The 2023 Directions have changed the landscape, and a GP refusal is not exceptional — it is now the norm in many areas.
Instruct an independent social worker early. The earlier in the deputyship process the COP3 assessment is commissioned, the less likely you are to face delays at the court stage.
Provide a clear referral letter setting out the decisions covered by the proposed deputyship, any relevant diagnoses or conditions, and the urgency of the application.
Expect a structured written report — not just a completed form. A properly conducted COP3 assessment is a clinical and legal document; it should reference the Mental Capacity Act 2005 framework explicitly, set out the two-stage test, and provide reasoned conclusions for each capacity domain.
Turnaround times are typically 5–10 working days from assessment, depending on complexity and case urgency. Urgent deputyship applications can often be accommodated faster.
About the Author
Neil Courtney is a Senior Independent Social Worker registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188). He has worked in the care field for approximately 30 years and has been a qualified social worker since 2011. Expert Social Work Assessments has no affiliations or ties to any formal care organisation. Neil covers all 48 counties of England and all 22 counties of Wales for in-person assessments.
Instruct a COP3 Assessment
To commission a COP3 Part B assessment or to discuss a case, please contact us. We aim to respond to all solicitor and professional deputy enquiries within one working day.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are GPs no longer doing COP3 assessments?
The NHS England Primary Medical Services and List Management Directions 2023 removed the contractual obligation for GPs to complete COP3 Part B assessments. While GPs can still choose to complete these assessments, they are under no legal obligation to do so. Many practices now decline these requests due to clinical complexity, time pressures, and medico-legal concerns.
Who can do a COP3 if not a GP?
COP3 Part B can be completed by any registered healthcare professional with the skills and knowledge to carry out a mental capacity assessment under the Mental Capacity Act 2005. In practice, independent social workers, consultant psychiatrists, neuropsychologists, occupational therapists, and clinical psychologists all complete COP3 assessments. For most deputyship applications, an independent social worker is the most accessible and cost-effective route.
What are my options if my GP refuses to complete the COP3?
A GP refusal is now common and does not block your deputyship application. You can instruct an independent social worker or other suitably qualified practitioner directly, without the GP's involvement or referral. Contact us to discuss commissioning a COP3 assessment.
Is a social worker qualified to complete COP3 Part B?
Yes. A registered social worker with specialist expertise in mental capacity law and the Mental Capacity Act 2005 is fully qualified to complete COP3 Part B. Social workers are trained specifically in the two-stage capacity test and the functional approach to capacity assessment that the Act requires. Their assessments are accepted by the Court of Protection as a matter of course.
How long does a COP3 assessment take with an independent social worker?
The assessment itself typically takes 60 to 90 minutes, depending on the complexity of the case and the number of capacity domains being assessed. The written report is normally completed within 5 to 10 working days of the assessment. Urgent cases can often be accommodated more quickly — discuss timescales when you make your referral.
Does the assessor need to know the person before completing the COP3?
No. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 does not require the assessor to have a pre-existing relationship with the person being assessed. An independent assessor who has not previously treated or worked with the individual is in many cases preferable for Court of Protection purposes, as it removes any concern about prior clinical relationships influencing the assessment outcome.
Can a COP3 assessment be carried out remotely?
For most deputyship applications, the Court of Protection expects a face-to-face assessment, particularly where the person being assessed has a condition affecting communication or behaviour. Remote assessments may be acceptable in limited circumstances — for example, for overseas clients or where significant mobility issues make attendance difficult. Discuss the specific circumstances of your case when you make your referral.
What does the 2023 NHS England Direction actually say?
The NHS England Primary Medical Services and List Management Directions 2023 removed mental capacity assessments for Court of Protection purposes from the scope of GPs' core NHS contractual duties. The full direction is a public document available from NHS England. The key practical effect is that GPs are no longer obligated to complete COP3 Part B as part of their NHS contract, though they retain clinical discretion to do so if they consider themselves suitably qualified.




Comments