top of page
You are in Safe Hands

Mental Capacity and Testamentary Capacity: What's the Difference?

Writer: Neil Courtney
Neil Courtney
Sep 26
9 min read

When a solicitor instructs an independent social worker to assess a client's mental capacity, a question often follows: does the Mental Capacity Act 2005 assessment also cover capacity to make a will? The short answer is no — and understanding why matters both for the solicitor commissioning the report and for the family waiting on its conclusions. Mental capacity under the MCA 2005 and testamentary capacity under the rule in Banks v Goodfellow (1870) are two distinct legal tests, assessed against different criteria, under different legal frameworks, and for different purposes. This article explains both, sets out the key differences, and explains when a testamentary capacity assessment should be instructed alongside — or instead of — an MCA 2005 mental capacity assessment.


What Is Mental Capacity Under the Mental Capacity Act 2005?

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 governs decisions made in England and Wales on behalf of adults who may lack the ability to make those decisions for themselves. The Act applies to a broad range of decisions: where to live, whether to consent to medical treatment, how to manage finances, and whether to apply for a Lasting Power of Attorney.


The MCA 2005 applies a two-stage test.

Stage one — the diagnostic test: the assessor must first establish that there is an impairment of, or disturbance in the functioning of, the mind or brain. This covers dementia, acquired brain injury, learning disability, mental health conditions, neurological conditions, and the effects of medication or substance use.


Stage two — the functional test: if a relevant impairment is identified, the assessor must then consider whether that impairment means the person cannot understand the information relevant to the decision, retain it long enough to make a decision, use or weigh it as part of the decision-making process, or communicate their decision by any means.


A critical feature of the MCA 2005 framework is that capacity is always decision-specific and time-specific. A person may lack capacity to manage their property and financial affairs — the threshold assessed by the COP3 for a deputyship application — while retaining capacity to make other decisions, including decisions about their estate.


What Is Testamentary Capacity?

Testamentary capacity is the legal test for whether a person has the mental ability to make a valid will. In England and Wales, the test is still drawn from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 — a Victorian case whose four-part criteria have remained the standard for over 150 years.

To have testamentary capacity, the person making the will — the testator — must, at the time of execution:


  • understand the nature of making a will and its effects

  • understand the extent of the property they are disposing of

  • comprehend and appreciate the claims of those who might expect to benefit (typically close family members), even if the testator chooses not to benefit them

  • not be suffering from any disorder of the mind that poisons their affections, perverts their sense of right, or prevents the exercise of their natural faculties in disposing of their property


The fourth criterion — often called the 'insane delusion' test — is the one that most closely connects testamentary capacity with mental capacity. An insane delusion is a belief with no rational foundation that a person holds unshakeably, even when shown evidence that it is false. If that delusion directly influences the terms of the will, the will may be invalid even if the other three criteria are met.


The test in Banks v Goodfellow is assessed at the point of execution — the moment the will is signed. This is a snapshot test, not a longitudinal assessment. A person whose capacity fluctuates may have testamentary capacity on the day they execute their will even if their general cognitive function is declining.


The Key Differences


1. The legal framework

MCA 2005 capacity assessments are statutory, governed by primary legislation and its associated Code of Practice. Testamentary capacity is a common law doctrine. No statute governs it — the test comes from case law, and the leading authority remains a nineteenth-century judgment.

2. The purpose


An MCA 2005 assessment is used to determine whether someone can make a specific decision now, or whether someone else must make it in their best interests. A testamentary capacity assessment determines whether a will is, or was, validly made. The two have entirely different downstream consequences: an MCA 2005 finding feeds into deputyship applications, care decisions, or Court of Protection proceedings. A testamentary capacity finding goes to the validity of the estate distribution.


3. The criteria

The MCA 2005 functional test asks whether a person can understand, retain, use and weigh information, and communicate a decision. The Banks v Goodfellow test asks whether a person understands the nature of making a will, the extent of their estate, the claims of those who might benefit, and whether any disorder of the mind distorts the disposition. A person can pass one test and fail the other.


4. The timing

An MCA 2005 assessment is usually prospective — it addresses the person's capacity now, for a decision that is or will soon be before them. A testamentary capacity assessment is frequently retrospective — carried out after the person has died, to determine whether a will they signed months or years ago was validly executed. Retrospective assessments rely on medical records, contemporaneous notes, and witness evidence rather than direct interview.


5. Who carries out the assessment

An MCA 2005 assessment for Court of Protection purposes — including the COP3 for a deputyship application — must be completed by a registered medical practitioner or a registered social worker. A testamentary capacity assessment may be carried out by either, though the field increasingly recognises that cognitive and functional social work expertise is as relevant as clinical assessment for the Banks v Goodfellow criteria.


Can a Person Lack Mental Capacity But Still Have Testamentary Capacity?

Yes — and this is the scenario solicitors encounter most often. A client is assessed under the MCA 2005 as lacking capacity to manage their property and financial affairs, which triggers a deputyship application. The deputy or family then asks whether a will the person made before the MCA assessment is still valid, or whether the person retains the ability to make a new will.

The answer turns on the Banks v Goodfellow test, not the MCA 2005 assessment. The deputyship finding establishes that the person cannot manage their financial affairs under the statutory framework. It says nothing, directly, about whether they understand the nature of a will, the extent of their estate, or the claims of those around them. Those are different questions, assessed against different criteria.

In practice, severe cognitive impairment that produces an MCA 2005 incapacity finding often also undermines testamentary capacity. But the correlation is not automatic. A person with moderate dementia who clearly retains insight into their estate and family relationships may have testamentary capacity even if they cannot safely manage day-to-day finances. The assessment must be carried out separately, against the correct test.


Can a Person Have Mental Capacity But Lack Testamentary Capacity?

Yes, though it is less common. The insane delusion criterion in Banks v Goodfellow has no equivalent in the MCA 2005 framework. A person with a fixed delusional belief — that a family member has wronged them, for example, or that an estranged relative is conspiring against them — may pass the MCA 2005 functional test for most decisions while still lacking testamentary capacity if that delusion directly distorts the terms of the will.


This scenario arises most often in contested wills, where a beneficiary who has been excluded challenges the estate on the grounds that the testator's beliefs about them had no rational basis. The question for the assessor is whether the beliefs that influenced the will were genuinely delusional in the psychiatric sense, or simply preferences or estrangements the testator was entitled to hold.


Testamentary Capacity Assessments Carried Out by Expert Social Work Assessments

Neil Courtney, Senior Independent Social Worker at Expert Social Work Assessments, carries out both prospective and retrospective testamentary capacity assessments applying the Banks v Goodfellow test. This service is available to probate solicitors, contentious estates practitioners, and professional deputies who need an independent assessment of a client's testamentary capacity — whether the client is alive or the assessment is being carried out retrospectively following the testator's death.


Prospective assessments are carried out in person at the testator's home or care setting. Retrospective assessments are produced from medical records, care notes, and any other contemporaneous documentation available. Reports are written to a standard suitable for use in probate proceedings or in correspondence with the opposing party in a contested will matter.


Neil is registered with Social Work England (SW22867) and Social Care Wales (W/5112188). Expert Social Work Assessments has no affiliations or ties to any formal care organisation. All assessments and reports are fully independent.

Testamentary capacity assessments are listed as a service on the Mental Capacity Assessment hub page under 'Decisions commonly assessed' and 'Services offered'.

When Should You Instruct a Testamentary Capacity Assessment?

The most common situations in which a testamentary capacity assessment is indicated:

  • A client wishes to make or update a will and their cognitive function is in question

  • A will has already been executed and a family member or beneficiary is questioning whether the testator had capacity at the time

  • A deputyship or Court of Protection matter has raised questions about whether an existing will is still valid

  • A probate dispute involves a claim that a will was made under an insane delusion

  • A client lacks capacity under the MCA 2005 and the question arises whether a statutory will application should be made under s.18 of the MCA 2005


For clients who also require a COP3 assessment for a deputyship application, both assessments can be instructed together. The COP3 addresses the MCA 2005 statutory test for property and financial affairs deputyship; the testamentary capacity assessment addresses the Banks v Goodfellow test


Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between mental capacity and testamentary capacity?

Mental capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 is a statutory test that applies to any decision a person may need to make — where to live, how to manage their finances, whether to consent to treatment. It applies the two-stage diagnostic and functional test set out in the Act. Testamentary capacity is a common law test drawn from Banks v Goodfellow (1870), which applies specifically to the ability to make a valid will. The two tests have different criteria, different legal bases, and different consequences. A person can pass one and fail the other.


Does a mental capacity assessment under the MCA 2005 cover testamentary capacity?

No. An MCA 2005 mental capacity assessment — including a COP3 assessment for a deputyship application — does not assess testamentary capacity. The MCA 2005 and Banks v Goodfellow are distinct legal frameworks. If testamentary capacity is in question, a separate assessment applying the Banks v Goodfellow test must be carried out.


Can someone lack capacity under the MCA 2005 but still make a valid will?

Yes. An MCA 2005 finding that a person lacks capacity to manage their property and financial affairs establishes that they cannot manage those affairs under the statutory framework. It does not automatically determine that they lack testamentary capacity. Whether they can make a valid will depends on whether they can satisfy the four Banks v Goodfellow criteria at the point of execution. This must be assessed separately.


What are the four Banks v Goodfellow criteria?

To have testamentary capacity under Banks v Goodfellow (1870), a person must: (1) understand the nature of making a will and its effects; (2) understand the extent of the property they are disposing of; (3) comprehend and appreciate the claims of those who might expect to benefit, even if they are not benefited; and (4) not be suffering from a disorder of the mind — including an insane delusion — that distorts their disposition of their estate.


What is an insane delusion in the context of testamentary capacity?

An insane delusion is a belief that has no rational foundation and that the person holds unshakeably even when confronted with evidence it is false. In the context of a will, the question is whether a delusional belief directly influenced how the testator disposed of their estate. If it did, the will may be invalid under the fourth Banks v Goodfellow criterion even if the testator satisfied the other three.


Can a testamentary capacity assessment be carried out after someone has died?

Yes. Retrospective testamentary capacity assessments are carried out after the testator's death, using medical records, care notes, GP records, and any contemporaneous documentation from around the time the will was executed. These assessments are used in contested will and probate disputes to determine whether the testator had capacity when they signed the will.


How do I instruct a testamentary capacity assessment?

To instruct a testamentary capacity assessment with Expert Social Work Assessments, contact Neil Courtney through the contact page with the referral details, including whether the assessment is prospective (the testator is living) or retrospective (the testator has died), the approximate date of the will in question, and any relevant background information. A free 30-minute consultation is available before any commitment is made.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Court Compliant COP3 Assessments

Navigating the complexities of mental capacity assessments can feel overwhelming. The jargon, the language of the legislative framework and the processes can all seem alien to the lay person. Sp let m

 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page